Not quite Sense and Sensibility
Sep. 13th, 2014 10:16 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
alobearGiven the current state of my brain (doing bonkers hours at work for reasons passing understanding - don't ask), the easiest thing seemed to be to just move straight on to Joanna Trollope's Sense and Sensibility.
It was a quick, easy, and pretty enjoyable read - but it still seemed rather meaningless, much the same as Northanger Abbey. Just transplanting the plot and characters wholesale into a modern setting without a twist to make it interesting results in a good story with likeable characters that are entirely familiar but somehow reduced by the lack of Austen's writing.
Much as I fall into the trap of getting enraged when people mess with stuff I like in adaptations, an adaptation has to be just that - adapted in some way, otherwise what's the point?
It was a quick, easy, and pretty enjoyable read - but it still seemed rather meaningless, much the same as Northanger Abbey. Just transplanting the plot and characters wholesale into a modern setting without a twist to make it interesting results in a good story with likeable characters that are entirely familiar but somehow reduced by the lack of Austen's writing.
Much as I fall into the trap of getting enraged when people mess with stuff I like in adaptations, an adaptation has to be just that - adapted in some way, otherwise what's the point?
