alobear: (Default)
alobear ([personal profile] alobear) wrote2023-02-06 11:57 am

Fortune's Rocks

Fortune's Rocks by Anita Shreve is set in 1899 and tells the tale of a summer affair between a 15-year-old girl and a 41-year-old doctor, which has far-reaching consequences for both their lives.

The story itself is mostly very predictable and not very interesting - and the age gap between the two characters made me very uncomfortable. While it's made very clear that the protagonist, Olympia, is very aware of what she's doing - and is, in fact, very much the instigator of the affair - the imbalance of power between her and her lover still made the whole thing seem very wrong. Particularly since the man is a doctor and thus very knowledgeable about the potential consequences of what he's doing.

However, in spite of all that, I found myself regularly reading this book well past my planned bedtime, drawn in by the strength of the narrative and my (sometimes a bit unwilling) connection to Olympia and her story. In the second half, the court case sections were a bit dry, since they were stripped of any emotion or reaction from Olympia as an observer - but the climax really surprised me with the decisions made, which were very satisfying and also drawn well in terms of the emotion involved.

The ultimate conclusion felt a bit abrupt and a bit too neat in some ways - but I also appreciated the sense of continued sorrow at the heart of the central relationship, and the potential reward for a difficult choice earlier on was satisfying.

So, an unexpectedly compelling read, which was challenging and difficult in some ways, but very well written and engaging.